Archive for July, 2008

Ann OToole: Open Source Devs are Felons

Saturday, July 19th, 2008
Image by Klaus with K

They simply don’t understand that installing the technical means of IP protection does have a serious effect. When the technical means is bypassed to steal it automatically becomes a felony.  –Ann OToole

My reply to her:

I understand that fully. If it becomes a criminal act to work on or distribute an open source client, that’s the end of open source. That’s what you really want anyway. You want to go back to your little sandbox world of Linden Lab controlling everything.

Those days are over, let them go.

One may wonder why this would make all open source devs felons, even if they don’t infringe on anyone’s copyright.  It has to do with the way the DMCA is written.  Distributing a “device” that “primarily exists” to bypass the “effective copy protection” is a felony.  This goes beyond merely using the device to actually infringe, distributing the tool is also a crime.

(Image: Klaus with K, from wikicommons)

The Virtual Grocery Store

Friday, July 18th, 2008

“It won’t be any permissions scheme, but rather fear, that will keep the grid masters lawful and in line. - Desmond Shang”

Not just fear, but the fact that the majority of people are honest.

A grocery store has no “technical protections” to prevent you from walking out without paying.

Sure, they could lock you in an airlock while they scan every item in your cart… but they don’t, because people are honest on the whole, and will pay for what they take off the shelves.

The old way was to have a clerk fetch everything from behind the counter.  Sure it worked, but it didn’t scale.

Now that we are moving to an “open store” paradigm, we just have to get over the fact that people will shoplift a little, and that our remedy is going to be pretty much limited to bring legal action against the most egregious offenders.

Woot

Wednesday, July 16th, 2008

I have my own taggy-cloudy-thingy-url on massively:

Jason Giglio

SLCC 08 Registration

Thursday, July 3rd, 2008

Why haven’t you registered yet?  These people did!

I will be presenting an Open Source mini-track, sponsored by Pleiades Consulting.  Hope to see you there.